Categorized | Commentary, Sports

What is the message sent when athletes get off easy?

By | Published March 03, 2010

Post to Facebook Post to Twitter

In the days following Tiger Woods’ apology speech to his wife, family, friends and the public, I have sat and thought about other athletes and the poor choices they have made over the past few years. After thinking about several different situations across all of the major leagues, I feel that it is time for all of “the leagues” to go back to the drawing board and fix their codes of conduct to send a message that this inappropriate and immature behavior will not be tolerated.

NHL star and recent gold medalist Dany Heatley, of the San Jose Sharks, was arrested and charged with felony vehicular homicide and reckless driving for driving his car at excessive speeds in a 35-mile-per-hour zone. This car accident led to the death of Heatley’s teammate, Dan Snyder. However, Heatley was offered a plea deal from the district attorney of Fulton County, GA, which merely required him to serve three years probation and receive a $3,000 fine.  Before the plea was reached and case was settled, Heatley was back on the ice and competing again.

Then there’s the NFL. The first name that comes to mind is Adam “Pacman” Jones, who was suspended for an entire season by NFL commissioner Roger Goodell. This suspension stemmed from several off the field incidents that violated the league’s player-conduct policy and were determined to be of a severe nature by the commissioner. Upon reinstatement Jones was suspended again for his off-the-field actions, and no longer plays in the NFL.

Goodell has taken a similar stance with Donte Stallworth, of the Cleveland Browns, by suspending the wide receiver for the entire season because of his DUI manslaughter charge. Stallworth served just a month in jail for accidentally killing someone while intoxicated. After Stallworth served his suspension, commissioner Goodell reinstated him for the 2010 season. Goodell said he will not hesitate to impose further suspensions if Stallworth does not clean up his act, but it’s hard to argue that justice has been served.

When the NBA was forced to suspend Washington Wizards guard Gilbert Arenas for bringing a gun into the team locker room, that was something that needed to be addressed. Since then, Arenas is facing criminal charges and might never play in the league again. Yet he has claimed in interviews since then that he wants to work to be a better role model and restore his image. Other NBA players who repeatedly have acted inappropriately are Ron Artest and Latrelle Sprewell.

After looking at the problems athletes have had off the field, people can see how Tiger Woods is just the next athlete whose actions away from the game have tainted his image in the eye of the public. After he stood up there in a somber tone and asked for us all to “believe in him again” I am skeptical to do so.

What message is being sent by these athletes to people all across the country when they can break the law and, because of their money and status, see minimal jail time, if any, and be welcomed back to their lavish lifestyle making millions of dollars within months? These individuals have been given tremendous physical gifts that most of us would love to have, yet they continue to put themselves and others close to them in harm’s way with poor decisions.

In the past few years, we have seen a St. Louis Cardinals pitcher, Josh Hancock, and Cincinnati Bengals receiver Chris Henry killed because of poor decisions that were made.  How many more tragedies must these leagues and athletes see before they start conducting themselves more professionally and valuing their gifts?

  • Erich

    Well said. But the Stallworth case is legit in my book. Yeah, he was driving drunk and that's obviously wrong…but the man he hit was J-walking the the middle of the highway. After he hit the man, he 911 immediately and cooperated with the police. The cooperation on his part lead to the lighter sentence. There is always more to the the story than the average fan knows…which explains why most fans wonder how someone can get off with something…it's because they don't know the details. But every other situation you wrote about was spot on…the worst one of all was Tiger and Vick. The other cases were accidents but Vick and Tiger knew exactly what they were doing for an extended period of time. Which is clearly inexcusable.

  • JJ

    I'm sorry, I dont think I understand this statement correctly. Stallworth took a man's life. A human life. And you think that good behavior gets him out of jail time? He shouldn't get credit for calling 911, he hit the guy. It shouldn't matter if he was under the influence, if anything that should make matters worse. The average fan may not know that the guy was J-walking, but the average fan does know that Donte Stallworth killed a man. Stallworth had a .12 BAC at 7 am. This guy was a father and a husband. He moved from Cuba to make a better life for his family. I have a hard time believing that this case would be “legit” in your book if this was your father or sibling. He also only served 24 days of that 30 day sentence.

  • Ryan

    “it’s hard to argue that justice has been served.”

    What is justice?

    “justice…if we only knew what it was…”

  • Erich

    This was obviously a case of negligence; unintentional tort. In the court of law there are legitimate defenses against negligence. One of which is comparative negligence…which basically says while Stallworth was driving drunk the victim was acting in a negligent manner as well. Which in turn, lightens his sentence.

    Secondly, the process didn't even reach the trial stage where a decision was handed down by a jury. Both sides worked out a plea deal, which includes Reyes' family. The victims family members decided on this plea deal. So the fundamental question is: who's business is it to determine whether justice was served or not? The family made this decision not anyone else. So from that aspect…it is legit. Not fair…but since when can someone overrule the court of law and determine something isn't fair?

    As for the overall message of your article…I completely agree…athletes sometimes don't realize how good they have it…

Follow Us on our Social Networks